Mansoor Ladha (@LadhaMansoor): It’s a question of colour after all

By Mansoor Ladha (Calgary, Alberta, Canada based Journalist)

Kamal Al-Solaylee, in his book Brown, has brilliantly described what being brown in the world means today. The writer takes a global look at the social, economic, political and personal implications of being a brown-skinned person. With hundreds of personal narratives and on-the-street interviews conducted over two years across 10 countries and five continents, Al-Solaylee enables the reader to slide under the skin of the “other” to experience being a brown person.

My own experiences as a brown person who used to live in a black society in Tanzania, becoming later a brown man living in a white society in Canada, is contained in my book9780889774742_cover1_rb_modalcover Memoirs of a Muhindi: Fleeing East Africa for the West. This true story begins in Gujarat, India, where my ancestors came from before settling in Africa in the 19th century. From India to Africa to Canada—that’s my story: from a minority in Africa to a minority in Alberta.

I am often asked: Why did you write this book? As a writer and journalist, I felt obligated to describe my experiences as a man of colour living in black and white societies alike and how colour has played a part in my life.

In the early 1970s Canadian employers demanded Canadian experience as a prerequisite to getting employment. New immigrants had to go through a vicious circle of “no Canadian experience, no job; no job, no Canadian experience.” Some Asian immigrants in the 1970s even anglicized their names in a desperate search for work. They believed their foreign names identified them as non-white immigrants, and so their job applications immediately went to the bottom of the pile. Badru Kanji became Bud Kanji, Sadru became Sam, Firoz to Phil and Kamru to Ken. But even that didn’t work. Personally, I saw this, and I rejected several attempts—particularly by co-workers at the Edmonton Journal—to change my name to “Mike.”

A painful experience that many Asians, including me, have experienced at some stage is when someone has yelled “Paki, Paki, go back where you came from”—in Canada, one of the most welcoming, multiethnic, multicultural and diverse countries in the world. For someone who thought I had already found a home in Canada, the phrase “Go back where you came from” springs several questions to mind: Where am I from? Am I from Dar es Salaam, where I spent part of my adult life? Or Zanzibar, where my parents and I were born? Or India, where my third-generation ancestors originated?

More disturbing questions follow: Will our children and grandchildren be accepted as equals in this country? Will they be asked where they come from? Should I be despondent because one person on the street verbally abused me? Will the colour of one’s skin always be an issue? This is the Asian diaspora lament waiting for a response.

Non-white immigrants bring their whole history—the history of their skin—with them when they come to Canada. Books written by minority writers have a vital role to play in humanizing the struggles immigrants face and in displaying the diversity of our society. Our books, TV shows, movies and articles need to reflect this reality.


Author: ismailimail

Independent, civil society media featuring Ismaili Muslim community, inter and intra faith endeavors, achievements and humanitarian works.

2 thoughts

  1. Lots of generalization by Mansoor Ladha. The extended narrative is of Asians who were expelled from Uganda in 1972 and some taken by Canada and some by UK for being UK citizens. Experiences varied in Canada and other countries who accepted us. The Canadians were admitting such a large number of brown-skinned for the first time as stateless but even then applied the points-system and warned many UK-qualified that their diplomas would not be accepted in Canada. Rejection rate was >60%. UK had no choice than to accept their citizens. That was “then”, this is “now”. Our people have settled down well in Canada, UK and all. Let me plug in my book on the subject – Uganda Asians: Then and Now Here and There. 12.8 years in the writing, 2.4m words. Lots of Ismaili interest but most of our people at all level of society and academia ignore. Mowla ji marji.


  2. I recently read an article titled: “Being Brown in Canada”..this is my response: Back in the early 70’s we were the very first large-scale migrants to Canada..Canadians at that time had very little to no exposure peoples of colour. Yes, many of us suffered varying levels of racism, and discrimination..mostly due to ignorance and lack of understanding. We persevered, we fought back, we did not succumb, ultimately, some 47 years later we are more “Canadian” than many Canadians born here. We have children, and grand-children, even great grand-children born here. We have inter-faith marriages, we have multi-faith families, our JK’s (at least the progressive ones..) are welcoming multi-faith families into JKs. Our world has changed, our Canada has evolved..”Brown” people are Mayors, and Senators, and Educators, and Professionals and Business Icons..and very much respected in the forefront of everything Canada.
    I am 62 years old. I was barely 16 when I came to Canada. I have East Indian ancestors, both my parents were born in Uganda, I was born in Uganda..when I get asked where am I from..I proudly say “I am Canadian”. Every time I hear the Canadian National Anthem played, no matter where I am, I always stand up, put my right hand on my heart, with moist eyes, pay my respects and gratitude to this great nation.
    Thank you Canada, I will always stand on guard for thee!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.